Our Cookies

At Michael’s Cookie Jar we are committed to making delicious cookies from scratch using time-tested techniques and real ingredients like butter and natural flavors. From the comfort of soft-baked Americana cookies to the sophistication of European styled shortbread, our cookies speak to every culture and taste.


Our #OvenFreshCookies are inspired by the home-baking we remember as children (and in some cases, wish we had!). And just like home, we are generous in their making. It all begins with butter…

$11.40/dz (1 oz size)   or   $23.40/dz (2 oz size)

Order #OvenFreshCookies for tomorrow or any business day after that!

Learn more about packaging options for #OvenFreshCookies cookies.

Fancy Tea Cookie Collection

fancyteatowerEuropeans have a long tradition of flavorful, bite-sized cookies. Our Fancy Cookie Collection includes many European style cookies in addition to other petite delights. Fancy Tea Cookie are available with a week lead time. $8.50/dz

  • Buttertwist
  • Mexican Wedding Cake
  • Currant Shortbread
  • Candied Ginger Shortbread
  • Raspberry Linzer
  • Lemon Poppy Shortbread
  • Espresso Shortbread

Order Fancy Tea Cookies (with one week lead time)

Seasonal Decorated Cookies

Every week at Michael’s Cookie Jar we bring you cookie designs that honor the season. All our decorated cookies are made with a delicious all-butter shortbread with a hint of orange oil.

Special Occasion Decorated Cookies

featuredimage-specialoccasionOur online catalog has some of our most popular designs for birthdays, weddings, baby showers and kids’ parties. Now you have the convenience of ordering online our most popular designs! Once you choose the shape, you’ll have some customization options available such as base color and inscriptions. These are available with a one week lead time.

Order Special Occasion Decorated Cookies
View Galleries of Decorated Cookies

Custom Decorated Cookies

featuredimage-customdecoratedIf you need a truly 100% customized design and you have a little extra time in your planning, we’ll be happy to personally work with you to create the perfect cookie for your event.  Our Custom Order Specialists have helped hundreds of Guests realize their cookie design dream!  We regularly hand-make custom cookie cutters and match colors to invitations or fabric swatches.  We can also custom bow wrap each cookie with a satin ribbon!

Due to the planning involved (and the necessity to make samples), Custom Decorated Cookies have a minimum of two week lead time.  Please note that we cannot make cookies with licensed designs (such as Hello Kitty, Mickey Mouse, etc).  If you’d like to speak with a Custom Order Specialist about your cookie needs, please click here to fill out an inquiry form and we’ll respond within 24 hours.  To speed up the process, if you have any images that would help us understand your needs, please upload them in the inquiry form.

Submit a Request for Custom Cookies Today

Logo & Photo Cookies

featuredimage-logocookieWhether you want to impress your corporate clients or your parents on their 50th wedding anniversary, we have something special for you! Our logo and photo cookies create a deliciously long lasting impression! To begin the ordering process for logo cookies, please click here to fill out an inquiry form.

Please keep in mind the following when filling out the inquiry form:

  • To speed up the ordering process, please upload your artwork on the inquiry form.
  • Your order is not placed until we contact you to approve the quality of the artwork.
  • The lead time for logo cookies is one week from the date your artwork is approved.
  • Artwork should be a PDF file or a JPEG at 150 DPI or higher.
  • If you’re not sure of the quality of the artwork, go ahead and upload it and we’ll check it for you.
  • We can individually wrap logo cookies


Submit a Request for Logo Cookies Today